Butterscotch White Chocolate Pudding
Delicious and simple, this is butterscotch pudding with a caramelized white chocolate twist. Say what? Yep, caramelized white chocolate is a thing, and you’re going to want to try it.
I made this recipe at the request of my sister, Ashley, who has an inexplicable love of white chocolate. I generally object to white chocolate, which, for me, is too one-note sweet and weirdly soft and generally a liar. For those of you who still live under the illusion that white chocolate is chocolate: it’s cocoa butter, with no actual cocoa bean aka chocolate in it, masquerading as chocolate. But I’m definitely pro butterscotch pudding and I hold a strong belief that caramelization redeems just about anything. Plus, I love having a dessert ready made in my refrigerator that I can pull out and seem like an effortless boss.
Overall, this was pretty simple to put together. Combine brown sugar, egg yolks, alcohol, and toasty cardamom. Melt the caramelized white chocolate in some milk, enjoy the amazing smell, then combine everything and strain. Pour it into ramekins, cover and put them in a pressure cooker to steam for all of 9 minutes. The hardest part might be waiting for these to chill to eating temperature!
Although the original recipe calls for rum, we are solidly a whiskey household and rarely have rum on hand. I’m happy to report that the whiskey was a delicious substitution and I personally did not miss the added sweetness from the rum at all. I tend to be into less sweet desserts in general, so if you’re into rum, you do you.
This recipe does call for some special tools - first off, you need a pressure cooker or Instant Pot. Although it’s an extra tool, it helps you avoid the need to stand over a hot stove stirring vigorously while the mixture thickens up. Next, you need to have a ramekins, espresso cups, or other heatproof bowls. This also could work with a larger heatproof bowl or soufflé dish as a family style dessert (see note below).
Butterscotch White Chocolate Pudding
Time: 1 hour + 3 hours chilling || Servings: 6 || Source: Dinner in an Instant by Melissa Clark
Heavy cream - 1 1/2 cups
Whole milk - 1/2 cup
Dulcey blond chocolate or butterscotch chips - 6 oz
Large egg yolks - 5
Dark brown sugar - 1/3 cup, packed
Whiskey or rum - 2 tsp or to taste
Cardamom or nutmeg - 1/2 tsp
Kosher salt - 1/8 tsp
Crème fraîche or whipped cream, for serving
Chocolate shavings, for serving
In a heavy bottomed pan, heat the cream and milk until steaming and just starting to simmer. Be careful not to overheat and scald the milk. Turn off the heat, then whisk in the blond chocolate or butterscotch chips until melted and well incorporated.
In a large bowl, whisk together the egg yolks, brown sugar, whiskey or rum, cardamom or nutmeg, and salt. Pour in the chocolate cream while whisking constantly so that you don’t cook the yolks. Continue whisking until the mixture is creamy and smooth, then pour through a very fine sieve into a bowl or measuring cup with a spout.
Choose your cooking vessel. If you want individual portions, select ramekins, espresso cups, or other heatproof cups that can hold 4 to 6 ounces. Fill the vessels of your choice with custard, then cover tightly with aluminum foil. Put a steamer rack into your pressure cooker or instant pot and fill with 1 ½ cups of water.
Arrange puddings on the steamer rack; if you have six, I recommend doing them in two batches so that they’ll cook more evenly and you reduce the chances of accidents — although you could stack them in a staggered fashion if you’re more coordinated than I am.
For the first batch, cover and seal the pressure cooker and cook on low pressure for 4 minutes. Allow the pressure to release naturally for 5 minutes, then release the remaining pressure manually. For the second batch, cook on low pressure for 5 minutes. Allow the pressure to release naturally for 5 minutes, then release the remaining pressure manually.
Once puddings are ready, remove them from the pressure cooker using oven mitts or tongs. Carefully remove the foil (be careful, there may be steam), and let the puddings come to room temperature. When cooled, cover with plastic wrap and chill them in the refrigerator for a minimum of three hours. Garnish with whipped cream or crème fraîche and chocolate shavings.
Notes:
If you prefer to caramelize your own white chocolate, heat the oven to 250°F. Cut white chocolate bars into cubes and spread out on a rimmed baking sheet. Bake, stirring every 10 minutes, for 30-60 minutes. When it’s caramelized, the chocolate will be the color of peanut butter. This has the upside of making your kitchen smell delicious.
If you’d prefer to have a single shareable pudding, or you don’t have enough small heat-proof cups on hand, you can use a 1-quart soufflé dish or other heatproof dish that will fit into your pressure cooker. In this case, cook on low pressure for 18 minutes. Allow the pressure to release naturally for 5 minutes, then release the remaining pressure naturally. Chill and garnish as indicated.
If you would like to make this ahead, the custard will keep in the refrigerator for two days before cooking. The cooked custards will keep for up three days after cooking.